Seizing a Challenge of the Champions victory was a goal Keith held for years before finally breaking through in 2026.
“This is my first one,” he said. “I’ve always been fifth or sixth, seventh. I’m an East Coast boy—I’ve got to drive a little farther.”
Keith turned a corner in the race at the inaugural Cowtown Showdown with partner Joel Lesh, where the team collected a $40,000 check in the one-day, one-class, high-stakes event. He stayed on the road for the Dixie National, San Antonio and Houston rodeo sortings, catching another TR Performance Horses ranch sorting. To get it done, Keith laid over in Lorena, Texas, with friends Brian and Sonya Buckner before finishing the stretch in Bloomsburg, Pennsylvania, for the Northeast Regional Super Sort.
“It’s tough,” Keith said. “It’s hard to focus on where to go and what to do to try to get qualified.”
Andersen/CBarC Photography
Two Horses, One Winning Formula
Keith split his round robins between two bigger horses. Metal Rebel, a 7-year-old Metallic Cat gelding out of Aristocrats Rose, carried him through rounds paired with Lesh and with Logan Wolfe. Little Miss Smooth Talker, an 8-year-old mare by Smooth Talkin Style, took the rounds paired with Chris Mangold and Kris Doornink.
“I’m a little guy, so I like them smaller—I usually get by just fine on those,” Keith said. “But the bigger horses can deal with the big, strong cows. Little ones, when they’re cowy and they cow down, you can lose some ground. Big horses, if they get that same kind of cow and they cow down, they’re at eye level.”
The Save of the Season
The defining moment of the night came with Mangold in the saddle alongside Keith, when a determined No. 5 cow twice tried to power past them.
“I thought I had him there, and he just kept coming,” Keith said. “Finally, I got him slowed down just enough that Chris could catch his head. I thought he was going to push right through him, but Chris was able to grab his head and roll him, and I came in the back door and backed him up. We were close to the buzzer, but if we hadn’t kept fighting, that cow would’ve gotten us for sure.”
The high-intensity moment had the whole crowd buzzing and hollering, and the stop was soon dubbed “The Save of the Season.”
“My mom, my dad, my fiancée Sarah, JP, Nelson Mas, all of my customers, Chris Morris, Stan Ayers—the list goes on and on,” Keith said. “Those guys never lost faith in me. There were days I wanted to lay in bed and give up, and they’d call and say, ‘Get up, you’ve got to go work horses.’”
Now, just a couple years later, Keith was not only named the Champion of the Champions but was also recognized for making rank among the RSNC’s Top 10 lifetime money earners.
“The good Lord took it all away,” Keith said. “And then He gives it back tenfold.”
From The Ranch Sorter
Summer 2026 Issue
This article appears in the Summer 2026 issue of The Ranch Sorter.
